Born on St Patrick's Day: Happy 115th Mary

They say that its good luck to be Irish, and that the luckiest of all are those who are born on St Patrick's Day. No doubt this is what was said the day that my great grandmother was born. However, her life was not necessarily filled with the good luck that the superstition had predicted. As much as she had a hard life, her life was also an "ordinary" one of a young British immigrant to Canada. Despite that, the simple life she led in youth was filled with fun. She embrace the changing times, new found freedoms, and innovations. Its the heirlooms from that chapter of her life that fascinate me the most because they show aside to her that none of my relatives knew - a woman who was happy. So today, I am going to share the side of her that one of those heirlooms tells. I have a small black autograph book that was hers.  At almost 100 years old, the book binding has all but disintegrated yet the leather cover is in near pristine condition and the partially bound pages are al...
Post a Comment

Is that my Ancestor?: A case study

If your researching somebody with a relatively common name, the odds are you have asked yourself the question "is this my ancestor?". I know that I have - matter of fact I did so just last night when performing FAN club research (see here and here for more information). 

My great grandmother's lifelong best friend (Helena) had a very common name, so when I searched for her in the local newspapers I of course got a large number of results. The first few that I clicked on all mentioned her acting as the leading lady in theatre shows and silent films. This fit with the 1920's and was believable based on her age (a teenager). When you add in the fact she married a man, several years later, who was also working as actor in the early 1920's, it starts looking more and more plausible that this was her. At this point I had to stop and take a step back. One of my favourite rules in genealogy is: If it looks too good to be true, it probably is! As much as I knew my great grandmother was a fan of the glitz and glamour of the 1920's, she did not come from money. She grew up very poor both while living in England and Canada. The chances of her being best friends with a movie star was not impossible, but it seemed unlikely, so I asked myself several questions:

  1. How many women living in this city have the same name?
  2. How common is the surname? 
  3. Would another database help me make the connection?
To answer question #1 and #2, I decided to look her up in the 1922 city directory. If your choosing to use a city directory there are a few things that you should keep in mind. Firstly, they don't list the entire population. The city directory only has the names of working adults, and the heads of each household. This means that women and children often went unlisted. As a general rule of thumb, you won't find somebody until they are at least 16-18 years old (likely older for women). Secondly, the directories are normally at least one year out of date when they are published. (Yep that's right! The 1922 directory would have had info from 1920/1921 and not been completely accurate). This means that you often have to check a one or two year range on either side of the date you are searching  to ensure that you have performed a thorough check. 

In  my case there were no Helena's (or variations of that name) listed in the 1920-1924 city directory, but I did learn that her surname was quite common. If you were lucky enough to get several matchs, you can check out my post on city directories to learn how to tell which one if your ancestor. 

(Note the at the 1921 Canadian census was another great resource I did consult, and yielded the same result as above. If your interested in learning more about Canadian census records, you can check out the first post in my series here)

To answer question #3, I decided to start by googling her name with one of the plays/movies that she was a leading actress for. I decided to start with google instead of a more specific genealogical database (such as Ancestry, FamilySearch, etc.) because the newspapers made it sound like this woman was quite successful. If she boasted the resume that I had uncovered, surely she would have a Wikipedia page (or something similar to that) which would give me her birth information. I was right. Helena did have a Wikipedia page, and also biographies on several sites designated to early film stars! Soon as I looked at the birth information I knew that I had the wrong woman! This was NOT my great grandmother's friend. The Helena that the newspapers were mentioning was an American film star who was born almost a full 10 years earlier than the woman I was looking for!  

The situation that I have described above is a perfect example of how a common name and insufficient research could easily lead to an inaccurate conclusion or even cause you to start climbing somebody else's family tree. By taking a step back and asking myself three simple questions I was able to determine if the woman I was seeing the newspaper was really the same woman that I was looking for.  

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Ford's Folly and the Slum of Little Hell

Image
Battersea: The Sinkhole of Surrey During the Victorian Era, Battersea had gained the reputation as being “the sinkhole of Surrey” due to its widespread poverty and slum-like conditions. Many of the poor in Battersea were subject to irregular income from the building trades. For a family to scrape by in the winter they would have to apply thrift spending during the summer. This was often complicated by the reliance on alcohol which was used as a means of escape from the depression of living in such widespread poverty. The irregular income caused many of Battersea’s poor to frequently be on the move. On average a family lived in one place for less than two years before moving no more than a few streets away. After hopping from neighbourhood to neighbourhood the family would eventually return to where they were once exiled from, moving in only a few doors away from their former address. Ford’s Folly and the slum of Little Hell In Keith Bailey’s report Orville Road, Battersea: a Victor...
Read more

Researching Addresses that no Longer Exist

Image
Ever since I was young I have said that I wanted to see the place where my ancestor's lived. I never cared if it was a castle or if it was a broken down shack in the woods. What I cared about was that feeling I get when I am able to stand somewhere that one of my ancestor's did many years ago. I spent the past four years researching where in England my ancestors lived with the hope that one day I will be able to go there and experience this feeling. Like many people, COVID had other plans. Its been a year since I initially was planning to take that trip and it seems like it might be at least one more before it can happen. In the mean time I have been revising my route and furthering my research. One of the first things that I do when I get an address for where one of my ancestor's lived, is search for it on Google Maps. Depending on where you are researching, the area may have changed so much that it is almost unrecognizable when compared to when your ancestor lived. For ex...
Read more

Courting Disaster: The 1915 Niagara Trolley Accident

Image
The worst electric rail crash in Ontario’s history and the  3 rd  worst in Canadian history (at the time)  occurred at Queenston Heights in Niagara Falls on July 7 1915 . In total the crash of car number 685 claimed the lives of 15 people and was responsible for injuring 130 people.  To put the scale of the accident into context, more lives were lost and more people were injured during the 1915 trolley accident than British soldiers during the battle of Queenston Heights.  The main occupants of the trolley were members of Toronto’s Wood Green Methodist and St John Presbyterian Sunday school groups. The two church groups had organized a day trip to Niagara Falls for the approximate 1,100 parishioners (majority of which were women and children). The accident occurred when the two groups were on their way home.  All day the weather had been ideal for taking portraits and going picnicking, however towards the evening hours (approximately 7:15 pm) it began to ra...
Read more